Newton NJ Housing Market: Listings Doubled This Fall 2026

Newton NJ Housing Market:  Listings Doubled This Fall 2026
Newton, NJ Market Update

Newton NJ Housing Market: Listings Doubled This Fall 2026

The Newton NJ housing market doubled its listings this fall. See the $411,500 median price, how far over asking homes sell, and what it means for you.

Quick Answer:

The Newton NJ housing market is still a seller's market, but buyers have more room now. The median single-family sale price was $411,500 from Aug 17 to Nov 15, 2026. That's down 5.3% from this summer, but up 5.4% from last fall and winter. Homes for sale jumped from 10 to 23. Homes sold for 101.9% of list price, down from 105%.

What is the median home price in Newton, NJ right now?

The median sale price for a single-family home in Newton is $411,500. That's based on sales closed in the last 90 days.

This summer, the median was $434,500. So prices cooled about 5.3% from that peak. But in last fall and winter, the median was $390,300. That means Newton is still up 5.4% from that older window. Newton is also one of the more affordable spots in Sussex County. The county median was $485,500 in early November, about $74,000 higher. The median list price of sold homes dipped too, from $409,000 to $399,999. So part of the drop is simply which homes sold this fall.

Source: Garden State MLS

Are there more homes for sale in Newton?

Yes. There are 23 single-family homes for sale in Newton, up from just 10 this summer.

That's a 130% jump in 90 days. Last fall and winter, there were only 11. Back in my late September Newton report, the count was 13. More listings means you can compare homes before you decide. It also means fewer rushed offers on the first house that looks okay. For sellers, your home has more competition than it did a few months ago.

Source: Garden State MLS

Are homes in Newton still selling over asking price?

Yes, but not by as much. Homes sold for a median of 101.9% of list price.

This summer, that number was 105%. Last fall and winter, it was about 104.2%. On a $400,000 list price, 101.9% works out to about $7,600 over asking. This summer, that same home would have gone for about $20,000 over. Homes are also taking a little longer to sell. The median home sold in 24 days, up from 16 this summer. That's still only about three and a half weeks.

Source: Garden State MLS

Is Newton, NJ still a seller's market?

Yes. A seller's market is when there are more buyers than homes for sale.

One way to measure it is months of supply. That's how long it would take to sell every listing at today's pace. Under six months usually means a seller's market. Newton closed 20 sales in 90 days, or about 7 a month. With 23 homes for sale, that's about 3.5 months of supply. This summer, it was only about 1.4 months. So Newton is still a seller's market, just a much calmer one. Keep in mind Newton is a small market, so medians can swing.

Source: calculated from Garden State MLS data

What's it like to live in Newton, NJ?

Newton is the county seat of Sussex County, with a real downtown you can walk.

About 8,374 people lived in Newton in 2020, on about 3.4 square miles. The Sussex Superior Courthouse sits right on the Newton Green. Spring Street is the main downtown strip, home to the Newton Theatre. Sussex County Community College is in town, with its own Performing Arts Center. Memory Park has fields, a playground, and the town pool. Routes 206 and 94 meet in the center of town. Route 80 is about 10 miles south on Route 206. Kids attend Merriam Avenue School, Halsted Middle School, and Newton High School. Newton runs its own water and sewer utility. That's a big difference from most of Sussex County, where well and septic are common.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts

Source: Town of Newton, Town Profile

Source: Newton Public Schools

What does this mean for buyers and sellers in Newton?

Buyers have real choices again. Sellers still get strong prices, but pricing right matters more.

If you're buying, you can tour a few homes before you decide. Get pre-approved first, since good homes still go a bit over asking. Ask whether the home is on town water and sewer. If you're selling, price close to what's really selling now. Homes for sale have a median asking price of about $399,000. An overpriced home will sit while buyers look at the 22 others. Many buyers come from Bergen, Essex, and Passaic counties for more space and value. Show them what Newton does best: a walkable town with a small-town feel.

By the Numbers
  • $411,500 median sale price, Aug 17 to Nov 15, 2026
  • -5.3% vs. this summer ($434,500), +5.4% vs. last fall and winter ($390,300)
  • 23 single-family homes for sale, up from 10
  • 101.9% median sale price as a share of list price, down from 105%
  • 24 days median days on market, up from 16
  • 20 closed sales, compared with 21
  • About 3.5 months of supply
  • About $74,000 under the Sussex County median ($485,500)

The Bottom Line

Newton's market is shifting from hot to healthy. Buyers have more than twice as many homes to pick from, and bidding wars have cooled. Sellers still get a little over asking when they price it right. If you're thinking about a move in Newton, I'm happy to walk you through your numbers.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the median home price in Newton, NJ?
The median single-family sale price was $411,500 from Aug 17 to Nov 15, 2026. That's according to Garden State MLS data.

Is it a good time to buy a home in Newton, NJ?
It's a better time than this summer. There are 23 homes for sale, up from 10, and homes sell closer to asking.

How long does it take to sell a house in Newton?
The median home sold in 24 days over the last 90 days. Well-priced homes often go faster.

Do homes in Newton have city water and sewer?
Newton runs its own water and sewer utility, so many homes in town are connected. Always confirm it for the specific home you're buying.

Sources

  • Garden State MLS (https://www.gsmls.com/): Market Condition Statistics Report (1004 MC), Newton Town single-family homes, Nov 15, 2025 to Nov 15, 2026. Supports median sale price, list prices, active listings, days on market, closed sales, and sale-to-list ratio. Also the Sussex County single-family report of Nov 2, 2026 for the $485,500 county median. Info deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
  • U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts (https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/): Newton population of 8,374 (2020 Census) and land area of 3.36 square miles.
  • Town of Newton, Town Profile (https://newtontownhall.com/): county seat, Newton Theatre on Spring Street, Sussex County Community College Performing Arts Center, Memory Park, town water and sewer utility, Routes 206 and 94, distance to Route 80.
  • Newton Public Schools (https://www.newtonnj.org/): Merriam Avenue School, Halsted Middle School, and Newton High School.
  • Months of supply, percent changes, and dollars over asking are estimates calculated from the Garden State MLS figures above.

Nina Fradl is a REALTOR® with United Real Estate North Jersey, serving all of Sussex County, including Andover Boro, Andover Twp, Branchville Boro, Byram Twp, Frankford Twp, Franklin Boro, Fredon Twp, Green Twp, Hamburg Boro, Hampton Twp, Hardyston Twp, Hopatcong Boro, Lafayette Twp, Montague Twp, Newton Town, Ogdensburg Boro, Sandyston Twp, Sparta Twp, Stanhope Boro, Stillwater Twp, Sussex Boro, Vernon Twp, Walpack Twp, and Wantage Twp.

Nina Fradl, REALTOR®
United Real Estate North Jersey
Phone: (973) 490-4999
Email: Nina@NinaFradl.com

Curious what your home is worth? Find out instantly → https://LearnMyHomesValue.com