Lake Mohawk NJ Housing Market: Homes Now Sell at Asking
Lake Mohawk NJ Housing Market: Homes Now Sell at Asking
The Lake Mohawk NJ housing market is still a seller's market, but the summer bidding wars are over. The median single-family sale price was $560,000 from Aug 20 to Nov 18, 2026. That's down 11.5% from this summer, but up 13.7% from last fall and winter. Homes sold for 100.2% of list price, down from 103.2%. There were 26 homes for sale, or about 2.8 months of supply.
What is the median home price at Lake Mohawk, NJ right now?
The median sale price for a single-family home at Lake Mohawk is $560,000. That's based on sales closed in the last 90 days.
This summer, the median hit $632,500. Last fall and winter, it was $492,500. So prices cooled from a summer high, but they're still well above last fall and winter. Part of the dip is simply which homes sold. The median list price of sold homes slipped from $599,000 to $575,000. Lake Mohawk's median is about $74,500 above the Sussex County median of $485,500 from early November.
Source: Garden State MLS
Are Lake Mohawk homes still selling over asking price?
Not really. Homes sold for a median of 100.2% of list price in the last 90 days. That's right at asking.
This summer, the number was 103.2%. On a $550,000 list price, that's the difference between about $17,500 over asking and right at asking. Last fall and winter, homes also sold right at 100%. So the summer rush looks like the outlier, not the new normal. Good homes still draw strong offers. Buyers just aren't paying big premiums to win them.
Source: Garden State MLS
Are there more homes for sale at Lake Mohawk?
About the same as summer. There are 26 active single-family listings, up from 25.
Last fall and winter, there were only 15. Lake Mohawk closed 28 sales in 90 days, or about 9 a month. With 26 homes for sale, that's roughly 2.8 months of supply. Under six months usually means a seller's market. So sellers still have the edge, but buyers aren't fighting over every listing. One thing to watch: the median list price of all homes listed was $599,000. That's about $39,000 above what buyers actually paid.
Source: calculated from Garden State MLS data
How fast are Lake Mohawk homes selling?
The median home sold in 28 days. That's up from 19 days this summer.
Last fall and winter, the median was 29 days. So homes are back to a normal pace after a fast summer. Closings held about steady, with 28 sales compared with 30 last quarter. Keep in mind this is a small market. With fewer than 30 sales per quarter, a few big lakefront sales can move the median a lot.
Source: Garden State MLS
Is Lake Mohawk in Sparta or Byram?
Both. Lake Mohawk sits mostly in Sparta Township, with a piece in Byram Township.
The lake was built in the mid-1920s by the Arthur D. Crane Company, on farmland in the Wallkill River valley. Today it's about 800 acres and it's the source of the Wallkill River. The boardwalk and White Deer Plaza, with their Tudor-style buildings, are on the National Register of Historic Places. About 9,759 people live in the Lake Mohawk area, per the 2020 Census. Here's why the town line matters to buyers. On the Sparta side, kids go to Sparta schools, from Alpine Elementary through Sparta High School. On the Byram side, kids go to Byram Township schools through 8th grade, then Lenape Valley Regional High School. Taxes are different too. And some Byram-side homes still have a Sparta mailing address, so always check the actual township.
Source: Lake Mohawk Country Club, Wikipedia, Sparta Township Public Schools
What should buyers know before buying at Lake Mohawk?
Lake Mohawk is a private lake, so ask about club membership and dues before you write an offer.
The Lake Mohawk Country Club runs the lake. Owners of dues-paying properties in the Lake Mohawk Reservation become regular members. Ask the seller for the current dues, any special assessments, and any one-time fees. Ask about the water and septic too. Sparta's water utility runs a Lake Mohawk water system. Both Sparta and Byram run septic pumping programs for the Lake Mohawk area. Get the septic inspected, and ask for the pumping records.
Source: Lake Mohawk Country Club By-Laws, Sussex County Wastewater Management Plan
What does this mean for buyers and sellers?
Buyers have more room to negotiate. Sellers still have a strong market but need to price smart.
If you're buying, you can make a fair offer without bracing for a bidding war. Get pre-approved first so you can move fast on the right home. Check the township, the club dues, and the septic before you commit. If you're selling, buyers have time to compare now. A home priced too high will sit, and the median listing is already above what buyers paid. Price it right on day one and you'll likely be under contract in about four weeks. Many buyers here are coming from Bergen, Essex, and Passaic counties for lake life. Show them the lake access, the beach, and the walk to the boardwalk.
- $560,000 median sale price, Aug 20 to Nov 18, 2026
- -11.5% vs. the prior 90 days, +13.7% vs. last fall and winter
- 100.2% median sale price as a share of list price, down from 103.2%
- 26 active single-family listings
- 28 days median days on market, up from 19
- 28 closed sales
- About 2.8 months of supply
The Bottom Line
Lake Mohawk's hot summer has cooled into a steadier fall market. Prices dipped from their summer high but are still up 13.7% from last fall and winter. Homes now sell right at asking, in about four weeks. Thinking about a move on or near the lake? I'm always happy to walk you through the numbers for your street.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the median home price at Lake Mohawk, NJ?
The median single-family sale price was $560,000 from Aug 20 to Nov 18, 2026. That's according to Garden State MLS data.
Are Lake Mohawk homes selling over asking?
Not much anymore. Homes sold for a median of 100.2% of list price, down from 103.2% this summer.
Is Lake Mohawk in Sparta or Byram?
Both. Most of Lake Mohawk is in Sparta Township, and part of it is in Byram Township. The township sets your schools and taxes.
Do you have to join the club to live at Lake Mohawk?
Owners of dues-paying properties in the Lake Mohawk Reservation become regular members of the Lake Mohawk Country Club. Ask the seller for the current dues and fees.
Sources
- Garden State MLS (https://www.gsmls.com/): Market Condition Statistics Report (1004 MC), single-family homes in the Lake Mohawk subdivision, Sussex County, Nov 18, 2025 to Nov 18, 2026. Supports median sale price, list prices, active listings, days on market, closed sales, and sale-to-list ratio. Info deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
- Sussex County median ($485,500) is from the Garden State MLS single-family county report run Nov 2, 2026.
- Months of supply and price differences are estimates calculated from the Garden State MLS figures above.
- Lake Mohawk Country Club, Lake Mohawk History (https://www.lakemohawkcc.com/Discover-Lake-Mohawk): Crane Company history, Sparta and Byram land.
- Lake Mohawk Country Club By-Laws (https://www.lakemohawkcc.com/files/ByLaws2024.pdf): regular membership for owners of dues-paying properties.
- Wikipedia, Lake Mohawk, New Jersey (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Mohawk,_New_Jersey): lake size, Wallkill River, National Register listing, 2020 population.
- Sparta Township Public Schools (https://sparta.org/page/school-registration): Sparta school grade levels.
- Sussex County Wastewater Management Plan, Appendix G (https://www.sussex.nj.us/documents/planning/wmp/2017/Appendix-G.pdf): Sparta and Byram Lake Mohawk septic management programs.
- Sparta Independent, Lake Mohawk water system (https://spartaindependent.com/news/lake-mohawk-homes-that-tested-high-for-lead-now-test-low-BL1409838): Sparta Water Utility's Lake Mohawk system.
Nina Fradl is a REALTOR® with United Real Estate North Jersey, serving all of Sussex County, including Andover Boro, Andover Twp, Branchville Boro, Byram Twp, Frankford Twp, Franklin Boro, Fredon Twp, Green Twp, Hamburg Boro, Hampton Twp, Hardyston Twp, Hopatcong Boro, Lafayette Twp, Montague Twp, Newton Town, Ogdensburg Boro, Sandyston Twp, Sparta Twp, Stanhope Boro, Stillwater Twp, Sussex Boro, Vernon Twp, Walpack Twp, and Wantage Twp, plus lake communities like Lake Mohawk.
Nina Fradl, REALTOR®
United Real Estate North Jersey
Phone: (973) 490-4999
Email: Nina@NinaFradl.com
Curious what your home is worth? Find out instantly → https://LearnMyHomesValue.com